|
MARVA COLLINS
Excerpts from Ordinary
Children, Extraordinary Teachers and Marva
Collins’ Way
BACKGROUND
Marva Collins began her teaching career in
Monroe County Training School, Alabama as a nineteen-year-old in
1957. Two years later she moved to Garfield Park, a suburb on
the west side of Chicago. Teaching took on a new dimension when
she began teaching children from the inner city. Although she
knew little about educational theory to begin with, the help of
experienced colleagues, natural talent, and years of her own
teaching experience made Marva an excellent teacher.
Becoming disillusioned by the failure of the
public school system and the lack of real educating being done,
she left her teaching position and decided to start her own
school. Westside Prep opened its doors in September 1975 with
four students. By 1980, enrollment had increased to two hundred
students with a waiting list of five hundred more. Working with
students having the worst of backgrounds, those who were working
far below grade level, and even those who had been labeled as "unteachable,"
Marva was able to overcome the obstacles. News of third grade
students reading at ninth grade level, four-year-olds learning
to read in only a few months, outstanding test scores,
disappearance of behavioral problems, second-graders studying
Shakespeare, and other incredible reports, astounded the public.
What was the secret of her success with these
inner city children —or this "miracle" as many called it? The
answer lay in her love for each one of her students, a positive
approach to education, complete dedication to her teaching role,
a refusal to give up, and a great deal of common sense.
AVOIDING MEDIOCRITY AS A TEACHER
"…make the poor student good and the good
student superior…" OCET, p. 9
"The good ones [teachers] are constantly
trying to find answers; the poor ones are constantly making
excuses." OCET, p. 11
"Some teachers think that just what is given
to them in the classroom is all there is to be used. These are
very poor teachers. You have to go beyond." OCET, p. 20
"To just read what is given to me in a
classroom and not explore other means and not explore other
connecting topics, still guarantees failure as a teacher.
Learning is everywhere. I think that is the one thing that is
missing in the minds of many teachers. Everything in life has
knowledge attached to it, and students are just waiting to learn
things." OCET, p. 21
"We can all pay teachers to teach, but how
much do you really pay a teacher to care?" A dedicated staff
will "take personally the failure of just one child." OCET,
p. 23
A school will only work "because of motivated
leadership and dedication from the teachers." OCET, p. 23
"Students may know nothing, they may be
complete illiterates, but they know when we know, and they
respect when we know. A good teacher must be more than a 2x4
teacher —bounded by the four walls of a classroom and the two
covers of a book. I have a passion for being the very best
teacher than I can be." OCET, p. 27
"I hear teachers and educators complaining
about how far a child is behind; what a child doesn’t
know…That’s what we’re there for. It’s not a problem. You can
see it as a problem, or you can see it as a challenge…you
innately have all the right stuff that it takes to make a good
teacher, if you eradicate yourself of the idea that these
children cannot learn." OCET, pp. 34-35
"…you can only do one day at a time. You
can’t teach a whole year in one day. Prepare to be the very best
teacher you can be that one day, in that classroom. Then come
home Day One and prepare to be the very best teacher you can be
on Day Two." OCET, p. 40
Have a positive attitude toward teaching.
"…think of the power that you possess to manage a whole group of
children. You can bend them like a piece of putty. You can make
them what you want." OCET, p. 42
"…teach every day. Do whatever profession
you’re in, do it every day, every moment, as if the whole world
were watching. I teach as if Jesus Christ Himself were in that
classroom. And when you do that, you’re bound to see great
things happening." OCET, p. 43
"Each of us can make a difference. Each of us
has what it takes to make a difference —and that’s a passion for
being excellent in what we do …All of us are what we are, and
are where we are, because of the excellence of somebody before
us." OCET, p. 44
The "miracle" of teaching is "…dedication,
common-sense, determination, and a love for our students."
OCET, p. 109
"… most human beings are as good as they are
because some unknown teacher cared enough to continue polishing
until a shiny luster came shining through; because some teacher
cared enough to remove the previous fetid tags and labels of
failure from their psyches." OCET, p. 152
FOSTERING A POSITIVE ATTITUDE TOWARD LEARNING
"…the teacher can never write anything
negative about a child…Everything is positive." OCET,
p.10
"…find something positive to say about a
child every morning." OCET, p. 11
"When our children walk in the door, I say,
‘Welcome to success. Say goodbye to failure because you are not
going to fail. I’m not going to let you fail.’" OCET, p.
16
"We have created an attitude that puts joy
back into learning, that creates satisfaction at doing something
correctly." OCET, p. 20
"We always find something positive to say
about their papers — ‘Very good, but let’s proofread this.’ No
teacher ever uses the words, ‘That’s wrong.’ We always find
something positive to say about a child." OCET, p. 26
"Create an ambience of positiveness in the
classroom where children learn that it takes more courage to be
wrong than to play it safe without ever responding to
questions." OCET, p. 110
"Children respond to love and positive
feedback rather than negative programming." OCET, p. 110
"Write encouraging notes to children, not
just when they are in trouble." OCET, p. 111
"Never let students say ‘I can’t.’ Say to
them, ‘We remove the ‘t’ from the ‘can’t’ and we have ‘can.’"
OCET, p. 111
"When a child gives an incorrect answer, say,
‘Very good try, but not quite.’" OCET, p. 113
"Praise is essential in developing the right
attitude toward learning and toward school. We all know this in
theory. In practice we often forget the importance of praise in
dealing with children." MCW, pp. 42-43
DISCIPLINE
"…I usually detect a child who wants to act
out…I stand right behind that child…and talk directly to him
because the children who are behaving do not need my attention.
[These children] usually see themselves as failures." It is good
to "give them a taste of success." OCET, pp. 15
"In our school, the children do not give a
‘problem child’ an audience. Therefore, there is no need for him
to act out; there is no laughing if he gets smart-alecky or if
he comes out with a comment." OCET, p. 16
"…turn disciplinary situations into positive
lessons…react positively to whatever children do…I think we tend
to make too much out of nothing." OCET, p. 17
- If a child is drawing in class, compliment him on his
beautiful picture and have him write about it.
- If a child is chewing gum in class, have him write a
composition on the history
- of gum; grade it as a regular assignment.
- Have a child write a composition or deliver a speech
entitled "Why I Am Too Bright to Waste Time in School."
- If a child shoots a rubber band, take the rubber band
away. Don’t turn it into a big deal.
"Usually when children act out, or when
children refuse to learn, it is a signal that something is
wrong, just as an illness or pain is a signal that something is
physically wrong with us …I consider myself parent and teacher.
It is my responsibility to let my lessons go for a few minutes
to find out what may be bothering this child. I try to empathize
with whatever is bothering him…" OCET, p. 18
"…we do not have the discipline problems that
most schools have…a child will say to another one, ‘You’ve taken
away my right to learn.’…Or if a child insists on acting up, we
will say, ‘Why aren’t you going to do that?’ Their retort to us
is, ‘Because I’m too bright to waste my time.’" OCET, p.
31
"…anybody can send a child to the office;
that’s a very poor teacher. The superior teacher always has the
idea that just one more time will do it…" OCET, p. 36
"Children respect the fact that you care.
They rebel against order, but they respect nothing else…They
respect the fact that you maintain your own classroom." OCET,
p. 36
"…ignoring it [negative behavior] is saying
negative behavior is right." OCET, p. 40
"Never place problem students in the corners
or in the back of the classroom. Keep them near you; remember,
we need to reach the troubled child quickly." OCET, p.
111
"Avoid telling parents negative things about
their children. You and the child attempt to solve the problems
that arise in your classroom. You earn the respect and trust of
your students, and you become a more effective teacher." OCET,
p. 111
"Do not send students to the office.
Remember, you, the teacher, must be able to handle your own
‘family and your own household.’ Your household in this case
being your classroom." OCET, p. 112
"Always make friends with each student before
there is a discipline problem." OCET, p. 114.
"Reduce ridicule and laughter in the
classroom by telling the student who speaks out that he or she
is very courageous, and it took courage to be wrong, but they
who stood silent or laughed took the easy path, and the child
who speaks out is to be praised not mocked. …create a spirit of
group effort in the classroom." OCET, p. 115
THE TEACHER’S EXAMPLE —CARING FOR EVERY CHILD
"The teacher sets the ambience in any
classroom. The teacher has total control over the learning
environment and children respond exactly to the atmosphere a
teacher creates. Teachers have been known to ridicule children,
or to laugh if a child cannot get the answer, even subtly.
Nothing could be worse for a child. In our school the teacher
and the rest to the children pull for a child to get it right."
OCET, pp. 10-11
A classroom is "like a total family, and it
starts with the teacher, setting the climate for support and
care." OCET, p. 11
"…when the other children see me accepting
the child, they learn to accept that child too …As a teacher,
you have to be accepting of everyone…" OCET, p. 12
"Some of my most important work with children
takes place at lunchtime…I have always insisted on eating lunch
with my children instead of being separated off with the other
teachers. I try to rotate, sitting next to a different child
every day." OCET, p. 12
"You say …by your actions, that you are
accepting that child and you expect the rest of the children to
accept him too…You are providing a model of behavior for all
children to follow." OCET, pp. 12-13
Get to know all of your students …fraternize
with the children. OCET, pp. 40-41
You establish rapport with the children "by
letting them know that you truly care about them." OCET,
p. 43
"Some students are not easy to like, but
never pick on a student. If you find a student with undesirable
behavior, go out of your way to like this student, and you will
find out that one day, you will like the student." OCET,
p. 111
HIGH AND CONSISTENT EXPECTATIONS
"Our approach pushes students to excel, and
students like to be pushed. They want to do well. They want to
succeed. And once they have a taste of it, they will never again
settle for mediocrity." OCET, p. 20
Be consistent in your expectations. "If we
allow children to use incomplete sentences in our classes, and
then we write on their papers ‘incomplete sentences’…We’ve
allowed them to speak in incomplete sentences, so they don’t
know what writing complete sentences is all about." OCET,
p. 25
"…when you aim low, there’s really no place
to go." OCET, p. 28
"…we are in a just good enough attitude
generation …we have to get back to that precision, that doing it
right again." OCET, p. 38
"We let them know whatever they do must be
the very, very best that they can do." OCET, p. 39
"The problem with our schools is that our
expectations are too low." OCET, p. 58
"Excellence is not an act but a habit. The
more you do something the better you will become." OCET,
p. 114
THE VALUE OF CLASSICS —NECESSITY OF TEACHING
VALUES
"We emphasize a total learning experience.
Not only must students be able to pass tests, perform
academically, and work through social situations, but they must
also have a sense of humanity and compassion." OCET, p.
12
"I’ll often say to my students that we can be
ever so clever, but we also have to learn first how to be human.
That’s why I emphasize philosophy as found in some of the
world’s classic literary works." OCET, p. 12
"Everything a teacher does affects children.
That’s why you, as a teacher, must be aware of what resources
are available, and you must know the moralities of what children
read, the actual lessons of life you want them to take into the
world." OCET, p. 14
"As soon as our children learn to read, they
must read one classic every two weeks and report it to us
orally. That means every teacher in our school must also have
read that book." OCET, p. 26
"…we’ve removed the values from our schools,
and we wonder why they behave the way they do. We’re expecting
them to behave the way we think they should behave, because we
grew up on certain values. But these children have not been
exposed to those values." OCET, p. 37
Teach children the classics with the lesson
inherent in each and we will have different students. "These
lessons will take them through life, not just a reading exercise
to fill the school day." OCET, pp. 58-59
"Remember a few years ago how lessons were
prefaced with Casey at the Bat; Paul Revere’s Ride;
Aesop’s Fables; and The Boy Who Cried Wolf? —the
classics that taught us the hard knocks of life and
perseverance?" OCET, p. 60
"Let us once again return the teaching of
classics and poetry to our children. Let us once again set our
children adrift in a sea of morality …Could it be that we have
allowed them to grow up without direction, without morals?
Without attempting to help them arrange the puzzles in their
minds? Without giving them heroes and heroines to believe in? Is
their definition of a hero just a sandwich? OCET, pp.
61-62
"There was a time in our curriculums in
American schools when virtue occupied center stage. There was
also a time when children memorized poetry and had to tell what
the moral lesson in that poem meant to them…The large objective
of schools some time ago was to train the moral character and
nourish the souls of the students." OCET, p. 76
"Pure scholarship purged of every other moral
concern is, in my opinion, dangerous scholarship." OCET,
p. 81
TEACHING IN GENERAL
"…syllogistic reasoning is so
important…unfortunately…We have gotten away from any kind of
deep thinking in our teaching…" OCET, p. 15
"We give all of our students daily exercises
in phonics. I am convinced it is the most effective way to teach
reading…" OCET, p. 18
"…all teachers need…to admit they do not
know…that he or she has a great deal left to learn." OCET,
p. 20
"None of our teachers has a desk. Every
teacher walks from student to student to mediate errors before
they become permanent errors…If you red-mark papers and give
them back to students a week, two weeks later, the errors mean
very little to them." OCET, pp. 25-26
"…we use a lot of the Socratic Method:
teacher-pupil dialogue. We are not much for the Xerox sheets
where children only have to check ‘T’ for true or ‘F’ for false,
or guess at multiple-choice questions. There is a dialogue
between the teacher and pupil every day. Our blackboards are
perhaps the most utilized tool in our classrooms." OCET,
p. 26
"Every child in our school is articulate.
Every child speaks standard English…Our teachers are correcting
consistently – all day, every moment, infinitely – throughout
the entire year. We have been correcting the children’s grammar
until they realize that there is the standard grammar that must
be spoken universally if we are going to function." OCET,
p. 28
Whether reading a story or teaching history,
you have to make it come alive. In teaching math, "remove
yourself from the pre-packaged lesson plans. For example, we’ll
take an entire group of children and we’ll go ‘Seven times
three! Plus two! Divided by four! Minus six! Plus eight!’ Every
child is listening because the next child knows that he or she
is It." OCET, p. 42
"Let us once again teach our children to tell
time as well as purchase digital watches for them. Let us once
again teach our children to tie their shoelaces as well as
provide Velcro closures for them. Let us once again teach our
children the multiplication tables before we buy them
calculators. Let us once again teach our children that the mind
is the best computer before we put them on computers." OCET,
p. 62
"The good school does not place readiness
above thoroughness, memory above mastery, glibness above
sincerity, uniformity above originality, and the rules and modes
of the dead past above the work of the living present." OCET,
p. 92
"To see things as they really are is one of
the crowning privileges of the educated man, and to help others
to see them so is one of the greatest services he can render to
society." OCET, p. 92
"Reinforce what has been learned in class. If
a recently-introduced vocabulary word is appropriate, use it
when speaking to a child. Say, for example, ‘I am chagrined at
your behavior right now.’" OCET, pp. 110
"Do not be afraid to be wrong and to admit
that you are wrong. None of us have all of the answers all of
the time. Have children proofread the blackboard for errors;
remember, children cannot create havoc and find your errors,
too. Make children a part of the learning environment." OCET,
p. 110
"I find that children often understand a
concept better when you take them to the blackboard rather than
trying to show them at their seat. This practice helps the rest
of the class at the same time, especially the shy child who will
never come out and say that he or she does not understand…One
child’s errors become a lesson for the whole class." MCW,
p. 43
"…I stress proper speech and pronunciation
with my own students. I try to get them in the habit of using
correct grammar when they speak and I have them read aloud every
day so I can check pronunciation as well as comprehension.
Having children read silently in class only allows their
mistakes to go unnoticed." MCW, p. 44
"Another reason for reading aloud is to build
vocabulary. A child reading silently skips over big words he
doesn’t know. When I am there listening to a child read, I can
interrupt to ask the meaning. The whole class benefits as we can
look up the definition, the base word within the larger word,
and the part of speech. I also have my students read aloud for
tone, inflection, and punctuation." MCW, p. 44
"I even have them read their composition
aloud every day. It makes children more conscious of sentence
structure, allows them to proofread for punctuation errors and
word omissions, and helps them develop a certain presence and
authority in front of an audience." MCW, p. 45
ADVICE FOR PARENTS
"Responsibility is often thought of as a
fourth "R." We can teach reading, writing and arithmetic here,
but much of the responsibility for your child’s education must
come from home. Being a responsible student means making the
right choices. It means paying attention to the teacher’s
directions, it means doing nightly homework, and doing just a
little more work than the teacher assigned.
Remember, school is a microcosm of the real
world. The reason most schools do not work is that school is
just the opposite of what is expected of citizens in the real
world. This, therefore, means that a child must practice being
above average in school so that they can take what they’ve
learned into the real world. This means giving each task in
school a real effort, not just doing enough to squeeze by.
Most experts agree that responsibility is
learned from parents. Here are some suggestions for using the
‘example’ and ‘practice’ method that will allow you, the parent,
to teach your child responsibility.
Let your child help you with household
chores. As you work together, be clear about the purpose of each
task. Praise your child for the good efforts and positively
point out the negatives by saying, ‘I think you can do this
better, don’t you?’ Explain that if you do not polish the
furniture that the wood will crack and dry out. This allows the
child to lean that most things we do have a cause and effect.
Thus the child comes to learn that some actions have
consequences attached to them.
Point out to your child that you, the parent,
work when there are other things you would rather do. Show a
child how to do a task correctly, and be patient as your child
learns.
Teach your child organization. Make certain
that each night, at the completion of the day’s homework, all
materials are put away and ready for the next day of school.
This means getting shoes and other personal items together and
all in one place so that the next morning will not be filled
with the frustration of: ‘You are going to be late."
Teach your child to be time-oriented.
Remember, in the real world, the workplace will not tolerate
tardiness and excuses. Therefore, teach your child to accept
responsibility for his or her actions, and not to make excuses
for shortcomings.
Make certain that you discuss the day’s
activities with your child on a daily basis. This can be done
while eating, driving to school, getting the child dressed or
any activity within the home." OCET, pp. 50-51 |